Final Essay

The challenge was an extremely rewarding challenge for me and went smoother than I had anticipated based on my limited interaction with nature in the past. Even though at times I forgot about it and felt like I had to make up for lost time, I was surprised by how every experience in nature rejuvenated me and brought a sense of calmness and peace into my life. The highlight of my challenge was stargazing at the knoll with my partner, I haven’t been stargazing in a few years so this experience was extremely grounding as it reminded me of how beautiful Middlebury is. It was also one of my favourite experiences because even though it was cold and rainy and foggy, I was able to have an amazing time in nature which gives me hope about the seasons changing. As we always talk about in class, there’s no such thing as bad weather, just bad gear. I am excited to bundle up and go to the knoll or other spots in campus to look at the stars again. The low points of the challenge were moments when everything was so beautiful and perfect that my hand itched towards my phone. I’ve read and heard about phantom pain but what I experienced felt like a variation of it, which showcased to me just how addicted I am to my phone. The fact that I could be at the waterfall and instantly think about how the view in front of me was worthy of an Instagram story makes me think about how our lives have become commercialized by social media. I had to reflect on what my values were, and why do I even use social media? Why is it that a perfect moment’s perfectness depends on whether or not it is worthy of an Instagram post? 

Regarding my relationship with nature – I would say it is complicated. My relationship with nature is definitely better than it was at the beginning of the challenge because the challenge forced me to be outside in nature in Vermont instead of just reminicing about nature over summer and winter breaks. Unlike a past lover, nature was everpresent and all I had to do was carve out 30 minutes in a day to spend time in it. That being said, the resistance I felt towards carving out those 30 minutes was shocking. At first, I used my schedule as an excuse or justification. As a Middlebury kid, my days were packed with classes and job search and networking and socialization. I barely had time to eat, how was I supposed to make time to be one with nature. However that time was carved out intentionally because of the challenge and showed me that I wasn’t a slave to my schedule. I dropped a class (not because of the challenge but it definitely changed the game), I tried to not spend all of my free time worrying about the future and instead just went on walks in nature. However, something else that happened during the challenge was that I started feeling lonely at Middlebury because it is my last semester and most of my friends have graduated. It was hard to drag myself out of my room when all I wanted to do was sulk or lay in bed and facetime people who no longer live close by. 

Reflecting on my own rules and policies for the challenge. I am surprised by how social my experiences in nature were. Even though at first I had resolved to do most of my challenges by myself in solitude, I was able to find solitude with company. However, I had to make sure that the people I went to nature spots with did not distract me with their technology use. For example, I went to Lake Champlain and sat on a bench with a friend, looking at the water. I was not on my phone but the people around me were. There was music playing from speakers as a run club ran past, the people sitting on the bench next to me were FaceTiming someone who wasn’t physically present to show them the lake, and my friend was sending voice messages to his family while we sat together. It made me think about how solitude is a privilege and not every spot in nature is going to be private. At Middlebury as well, when we as a class went to the TAM, an old man was hunting, and golf carts were driving by, and runners were using the track. My experience at Lake Champlain reminded me of my previous shared experiences in nature and how other people have the power to distort my experience through their usage of technology even if I create strict rules for myself. Since we were reading about the cellphone ban legislation in VT,  it made me think about concerts and comedy shows where people’s phones are locked in a pouch for the duration of the event to ensure that everybody is fully present in the moment. I wonder whether the same can be done on a routine level to police cellphone usage in public places. At the same time, should this policing be done in the first place? Or should we have signs advocating for cellphone-free zones? What about people who use cellphones in nature but don’t feel like they are missing anything out because they believe their relationship with their device is balanced and they aren’t trapped by their phone? A lot of these questions remain in my head at the end of the challenge. 

An insight that I gained during the challenge was that race, socioeconomic factors and exposure to nature during an individual’s formative years play a crucial role in how they connect with nature as an adult. During our weekly classes, I was astonished by the number of people whose goals were kayaking or camping or who had already experienced such moments in their lives. I was amazed when people were surprised by my admission that I would be scared in nature without technology for a prolonged period of time, because if I got lost, I would feel vulnerable in front of a stranger and be scared for my life. My experiences of growing up in Delhi, in a densely populated city with rampant sexual harassment, have made me wary of isolated spots as I always think about dangers to my physical safety when I think about remote natural locations. It was a sad realization for me that not everybody has the same associations. This aligns with the UK study (mentioned in the Nature Well-Being photo elicitation study) that found that some youth find nature scary and that the perceived role of nature to wellbeing may not be universal to all (Milligan & Bingley, 2007)

In terms of my experiences in nature, I thought about  3 parts of Kaplan’s restorative environment reading while writing my reflection. Specifically, I related to the 3 concepts of “whole other world”, “extent”, and “soft fascination”.

One of the best and worst parts about a volunteer session to the knoll is that apart from the 2-hour-long session, it takes 20 minutes to walk to the knoll and 20 minutes to leave and come back to your residence. However, the knoll feels like a “whole other world.” Kaplan mentions that restorative settings are often described as a whole other world because of the distinction between an individual’s everyday routine and time spent in the restorative environment. The concept of being away is fascinating to me because, based on Kaplan’s assertion, the knoll is more than a physically different location on campus – it is also a different experience that separates me from my Middlebury routine of classes, meals at the dining hall, and planning for extracurricular clubs etc. When I am at the knoll, I am not a student; I am a farming volunteer, which matches Kaplan’s description of being away.

Kaplan also adds that connectedness and scope are important to the experience of being away in what Kaplan calls extent. Kaplan mentions that the immediately perceived elements need to be interrelated so that the parts can constitute a larger whole. When I think about the knoll, I think about how the gravel part, the solar panels, the sign for the TAM, the blades of grass, the perilla leaves, and rows of radishes all appear as parts of a whole since they are parts of the knoll collectively. Megan always says that the knoll is made up of every handprint, every footprint, every seed sown by a visitor, and I think this aligns with Kaplan’s ideology that there can be a continuation of the world beyond what is immediately perceived. The history of care at the knoll and its ongoing care creates an abstract sense of continuation beyond the parts, which counts towards the experience of being away and feeling like I am in a different world. 

Lastly, Kaplan defines a fascinating stimulus as one that calls forth involuntary attention. Kaplan emphasizes fascination’s role in the restorative experience by describing how it allows individuals to function without using directed attention. When I look back at my 30 x 30 challenge journals, I think about how moments of calmness and solitude are tied with my attention being drawn to the sound of the water rushing through the waterfall, the repeated almost hypnotizing movement of water in small waves at the Otter Creek park and in Lake Champlain, the purpleness of my fingers after being stained by the stems of the Chard leaves that I was plucking for the Atwater harvest. In all of these cases, my attention was exerted without my control due to the sensory nature of my experiences, which provided a respite from the mental fatigue of having to concentrate on a stimulus. Instead, the soft fascination of how beautiful the water looked, how vibrant the Chard Stain was, and how loud the waterfall was transformed each experience in nature to a restorative and even healing experience in nature.